Of Cats & Closed Captioning

It was a road trip gone wrong. No, the car didn’t break down in the middle of nowhere and nobody got hurt. It was much much worse – there was a closed captioning crisis in our hotels!

The Hearing Husband and I were driving from British Columbia to meet family in Lake Tahoe. It was a scenic three-day, two-night and two-cat trip with Charlie, a 20 lb. hunk of Nellie-nervousness and 9-lb. Nickie who is fearless and curious.

Both cats intensely dislike traveling in the car and normally they ride on the bed in Flag, our 5th wheel which was waiting for us in San Jose, our next stop after Tahoe. So on this trip, they were less-than-happy campers, although personally, I think they were being over-picky in that feline way they have. What was to complain about? By day, they traveled in the back seat on top of their carriers watching the gorgeous scenery and by night, they stayed with us in comfy, pet-friendly hotels.

Our first stop was Wilsonville, Oregon. The hotel was adequate and for a $15 extra charge, the cats had full run of the room. But when we kicked up our heels to watch TV, there was no closed captioning (CC)—the standard accessibility for people with hearing loss which is mandated by the Americans with Disabilities Act. There was a CC button on the remote, but it didn’t relate to anything in the TV.  In fact, the only things I could control were the volume and the channel.

The Hearing Husband called the front desk; the girl said she’d look into it and get back to us right away. After 20 minutes I started getting anxious; it was Sunday and Downton Abbey was coming on at 9:00pm and it was now 8:40. I called back.

“Front desk, can I help you?”

“Mrs. Hannan in room 134.  How’s it coming with the closed captioning issue?”

“Ma’am,  I don’t even know what closed captioning IS – and the maintenance guy doesn’t know what it is, either!”

(I took a moment to mentally compose a patient answer.)

“It’s the words that come on the screen that help people with hearing loss understand what’s being said. It’s the law, you’re supposed to have it.  Can you bring me another TV set, like now?”

“All our TV sets are the same!”

“Really?  ALL of them are like this? The remote has a CC button on it that must relate to something, don’t you think?”

“I’ll call the guy again.”

Ten minutes later, I walk over to the office.  Downton Abbey was about to start.

“Hi, any luck? None?”

“You can fill out a complaint form to our manager who isn’t here right now.”

“But I AM here right now and I want to watch TV. (I realize I’m not going to win this.) Look, do you have an HDMI cable that can hook my computer to the TV so I can at least watch Netflix? The WiFi is strong enough, I hope?”

“Oh yes, I watch Netflix here all day long. (She gets on the walkie talkie). “Hey Joe, bring an HDMI cable to room 134 right away.  OK, he’ll be there in 15 minutes, guaranteed.”

Joe never arrived, so we read and played with the cats. I also wrote a nice email to the hotel manager explaining what happened. Still waiting for a response.

Next night, another pet friendly hotel in Klamath Falls, a ranch town in southeastern Oregon. I quickly dumped the cats out of their carriers onto the floor and rushed to check out the TV captioning.

It was there – except that you couldn’t see it. The size of the picture was too big for the TV and we could just glimpse the tops of the words at the bottom of the screen. We tried everything to adjust the picture but ended up calling the office. Jaime arrived in a flash—what a guy! Way better than the phantom Joe in Wilsonville. Jaime tried all the same adjustments that we did—after we showed him how the remote worked and what the different buttons meant. Sigh, what a guy.

Lucky for us, not all the TVs in Klamath Falls were ‘the same’. We gathered up our cats and bags and moved to the room next door where the TV and captioning worked like a charm. Unfortunately, Downton Abbey is not repeated on Mondays and  I still don’t know what happened on that episode (and don’t anyone dare tell me). Charlie and I watched the news instead. cat captioning

Checking out the next morning, I expressed my gratitude to the three staff on duty, along with a mini-tutorial on captioning and hearing loss and why I could talk to them but can’t understand TV without ‘the words’. Hopefully, the next families with pets and hearing loss passing through Wilsonville or Klamath Falls will find that the cats and I have paved the way for them.

About Gael Hannan

The Better HearingConsumer addresses the personal experience of living with hearing loss. Editor Gael Hannan and her occasional guest bloggers explore every corner of the hearing loss life with humor and poignancy. Comment Policy   Gael Hannan, Editor Gael Hannan is an author, speaker and advocate on hearing loss issues. In addition to her weekly blog at the Better Hearing Consumer, which has a passionate international following,Gael has written two acclaimed books, “The Way I Hear It: A Life with Hearing Loss”and “Hear & Beyond: Live Skillfully with Hearing Loss”, written with Shari Eberts. She is regularly invited to present her uniquely humorous and insightful work to appreciative audiences around the world. Gael has received many awards for her work that advocates for individuals to become more knowledgeable and successful at dealing with their hearing loss and a more inclusive society for them to live in. She lives with her husband on Vancouver Island, Canada. Books and other media Hear & Beyond: Live Skillfully with Hearing Loss. Written with Shari Eberts and available anywhere books are sold. The Way I Hear It: A Life With Hearing Loss. Available through online bookstores. Unheard Voices, DVD, vignettes from the hearing loss life. Contact Gael Hannan to order.


  1. Not being able to access closed captioning though the remote in hotels/motels is not uncommon. If the cc button on the remote doesn’t work, it is usually because there is a cable box to order movies, and they provide only the remote for that box. One can access the CC menu right off the tv itself. Find “menu”, “set up”, then using whatever combination of volume up/down and channel up/down until closed captioning is activated. On the flat screen tv’s, these button labels might be almost invisible, because the buttons are flat, like the tv screen itself. Usually they are on the bottom, or on the side. I travel a lot and have performed cc surgery on many a hotel tv. Or you can ask the front desk for the original tv remote, but this is usually an exercise in futility.

  2. My wife and I just stayed at the Luxor in Las Vegas during the 2016 CES Conference. The CC was not working on the new Samsung TV setup in the room. Of course the TV systems hotels have are far more complex these days than just the TV, but having a Samsung phone with an IR Blaster app installed I was able to navigate all the menus for the TV. No luck. Thankfully the hotel maintenance engineer assigned to fix our issue was very knowledgeable. The problem was actually with the set-top box that distributes the content. He had it working in no time. We were very happy.

    I also think it’s work buying a cell phone that has the IR blaster built it, like many (all?) of the Samsung models. I have used it so many times to turn on captioning at places like the auto repair shop and the Dr’s waiting room. Lots of places have TV’s and zero sound. So everyone benefits from the captioning in these situations. And you can change the channel. ;-)

  3. Here’s another side. Last year (2015) I stayed at a newly remodeled hotel near Baltimore. Everything was flawless: the front desk could answer my questions and the CC on the TV remote worked instantly. So I wrote a web-based compliment on a trip review site with 5 stars for the hotel. The trip review site denied approval for the posting, stating that it was standard.

  4. That’s the pits! No CC, I mean. Sorry the lower 48 sunk to a new low. Haven’t run into that on any of our travels – yet. You actually found someone who didn’t even know what close captioning is? I’m going to have to be more cautious in my expectations of the “tech” generation.

  5. I hear you. This doesn’t happen so much any more, but the days when I traveled from place to place as a hearing loss advocate, if I didn’t back in the day when I didn’t have Tom-who-was-hearing-husband-but-is-now-husband-with-new-hearing-aids, I was sunk. He’s the engineer and if I didn’t have him I’d be sure to bring my fm receiver with microphone and place the mic near the TV speaker. Not the best answer, but at least I didn’t have to suffer through a TV-less night.

    1. That SHOULD read: I hear you. This doesn’t happen so much any more, but back in the days when I traveled from place to place as a hearing loss advocate, when I didn’t have Tom-who-was-hearing-husband-but-is-now-husband-with-new-hearing-aids, I was sunk. He’s the engineer and if I didn’t have him I’d be sure to bring my fm receiver with microphone and place the mic near the TV speaker. Not the best answer, but at least I didn’t have to suffer through a TV-less night.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.