If Jimmy Buffet Sings It, It’s Gotta Be True

A May 2016 post discussed the monologue strategy adopted by some people with hearing loss who choose not to purchase hearing aids, or not to use them even if they make the purchase.  Those people were characterized by their tendency to

“speak loud and long, dominating conversations by turning a dialog into a monologue.”

That post must have hit a nerve because it continues to be a popular post in this section. In addition to describing the monologists among us, the post went on to describe two more inappropriate strategies adopted by people  with uncorrected hearing loss:

  1. Fake it:  nod and laugh at appropriate times. Unfortunately, it’s not so easy to figure out when to insert a laugh if you can’t hear what’s going on.  These folks get found pretty quickly and often come to our office after an embarrassing incident.
  2. Retreat: isolate, lose life connections, get depressed.  These folks are on a downward spiral unless intervention comes from an unexpected source.


Strategic Choices: An Audiologist’s View


The monologue post prompted the following response from an audiologist in the field, who says “I was talking with a friend last night about the Retreat Strategy.  The conversation went like this”:

Q : Why do so many people with hearing loss avoid wearing hearing aids?  Cost? Looks? What?

A:  Only 20-30% of people who would benefit from hearing aids actually get them.  Part of it is Cost, but we know that even when hearing aids are free (as in the VA) there is a large percentage of people with hearing loss that don’t get them.  Part of it is Looks:  stigma still exists linking hearing aids to age and infirmity.  But we know that factor is diminishing rapidly as more and more ear-level audio devices are adopted by young people using their iPhones and Bluetooth devices.

Q:  OK, it’s not all about Cost and Looks, but you still haven’t answered my question.  Why do people adopt these odd strategies instead of getting help with hearing aids?

A:  You’re not going to like this answer, but a major, often overlooked, reason that some people don’t get hearing aids is that they don’t care about hearing what others have to say.  That’s harsh, but it is true for some people who are in the habit of having others do things for them.  If you can get your wife to hear for you, why bother wearing an aid?  If you can turn up the TV, why bother to wear an aid (even though you’re blasting your neighbors out)? If you can get your secretary or lower management to handle everything and then give you a typed report, why bother to wear hearing aids?

Q:  OK, I’ll admit there are some people like that and maybe they were like that even before they had a hearing problem.  But what about people who don’t have anyone to do the heavy lifting for them?

A:  That’s where the picture gets very sad.  It is the Retreat Strategy.  People who have not worked on their communication and social skills often find themselves alone as they age.   Others have limited their social contact to only a few and if they lose those few, they are isolated.  Either way, depression is likely.  Uncorrected hearing loss cements the isolation and adds to the depression or kicks it off.

Q:  Oh, now I get it.  You know, Jimmy Buffet wrote about that along time ago in a song called He Went to Paris. It’s about a guy who starts out interested in the world, loses the things he loves, calls it quits, loses his hearing and doesn’t even care.


We Checked Out the Lyrics


Naturally, we ran out and found the lyrics, which are sad, to say the least.  Here are the relevant lines:

He went to paris lookin for answers
To questions that bothered him so…
Now he lives in the islands, fishes the pilins
And drinks his green label each day
Writing his memoirs, losin his hearin
But he don’t care what most people say


A Better Strategy


The audiologist finished by offering one more option for those with hearing loss:

Oh, there IS one other strategy that people use when they have hearing loss.  They come in and get fitted with hearing aids and then work with their audiologist to optimize their hearing.  That turns into a long and fruitful relationship.  Just ask our patients — all of them are out their socializing, communicating, interested in others, loved by others.  Hearing is a Win-Win proposition.  Don’t end up like that poor guy up above, sitting in the dark, playing a guitar all by himself.

1 Comment

  1. Yes people don’t care after a while. When people can’t afford hearing aids (profit margins are ridiculous) yes they will withdraw and develop the kind of relationship we don’t want people to have. So yes people are this way, but it was started by the greed of both dispensers and audiologists who yes care about their patients, but totally love the amount of money they make on a set of hearing aids.

Comments are closed.